• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer

Robison & Co

  • Home
  • Our Sectors
    • Accommodation Restaurant & Food Services
    • Breweries
    • Construction
    • Manufacturing
    • Media & Advertising
    • Not For Profit
    • Printing
    • Private Clients
    • Professions
    • Real Estate
    • Retail
    • Technology
    • Wholesale
  • Our Process
  • Why Choose Robison
  • About
    • About Us
    • Find Us
    • Our Team
    • What Our Clients Say
    • Careers
  • Blog
  • Contact Us
Client Login

Contact Us: 01730 265500
hello@robison.co.uk

Arrange An Audit

January 15, 2021 by Simon Gubbins

FCA TEST CASE – COVID-19 Losses – Supreme Court Decision announced today.

The Supreme Court judgment in the FCA Business Interruption Test Case was published today. The full judgment together with a copy of the FCA’s press release is available here.
 

In concert with our Network provider Marsh and specialist Law Firm Fenchurch Law, we are reviewing the content of the judgment in detail. However, the key message is that the Supreme Court substantially allowed the appeal of the FCA on behalf of policyholders and dismissed the appeal brought by insurers. Notably finding the following:

  • Notifiable Disease Clauses – while the Supreme Court took a different approach to the High Court, it confirmed that all the disease clauses before the Court were triggered;
  • Prevention of Access / Hybrid Clauses – cover under these clauses still faces challenges but may be triggered more readily. No requirement for a legislative step ordering closure and potential cover for loss of access to part of premises;
  • Trends Clauses – the Supreme Court was clear that trends clauses can only take into account factors wholly unrelated to COVID-19 and rejected the “wide area damage” arguments of insurers;
  • Orient Express – the Supreme Court determined that the Orient Express case was wrongly decided and that it should be overruled. This decision therefore has positive consequences for insureds beyond the scope of COVID-19 claims. 

Next steps
We expect to be able to issue a further communication next week, to provide more detail about the key findings in the judgment and we will let you have further details when we are able. Please speak with your Account Executive if you have any questions or concerns regaring the implications following this judgement.

Filed Under: Accommodation Restaurant & Food Services, Breweries, Construction, Credit insurance, Cyber, Fire Safety, Manufacturing, Media & Advertising, News, Not For Profit, Office Risk Insights, Private Clients, Professions, Real Estate, Retail, Small Business, Technology, Transport, Travel Insurance, Wholesale, Workplace Wellness

Previous Post
Next Post

Footer

Our Address

Robison & Co Ltd
6 Rotherbrook Court
Bedford Road
Petersfield
Hampshire
GU32 3QG
Policies

Terms of Business Agreement - Commercial
Terms of Business Agreement - Consumer
Privacy Policy
Cookie Policy
Contact Us

Phone: 01730 265500

Email: hello@robison.co.uk

Commercial Booking Page

Personal Lines Booking Page

Customer Contact Request Form

Mon-Fri: 9:00 until 17:00
News Items

____

  • Cyber insurance for SMEs is more essential than ever
  • Health and safety at work: What every business must know
  • UK business tariffs: What you need to know after the latest US changes
  • Distracted driving: Protecting your people and your business
  • Preventing theft and vandalism: How you can protect your business
Please follow & like us :)

 

Twitter
 British Insurance Brokers' Association (BIBA)

Authorised and Regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority       Robison & Co Ltd       Registered No. 4663937 England


Copyright © 2025 · Robison & Co Ltd Petersfield Hampshire · Built & Managed by THP Consulting